"For experience, when it wanders in its own track, is mere groping in the dark, and confounds men rather than instructs them. But when it shall proceed in accordance with a fixed law, in regular order, and without interruption, then may better things be hoped for of knowledge"
Francis Bacon, "The New Organon", (1620).
Geological Petroleum System Analysis (PSA) is based on a fixed model in which the inputs are subjective judgments based on experience. However that experience is not usually tabulated or analyzed formally. In a multivariate analysis there are a number of factors that are included if the statistical analysis of a "learning set" shows a significant correlation with the prospectivity. Therefore the model is not fixed beforehand. Here are a few examples of the multivariate approach.
In this study the learning set contained 90 basins, 63 with oil, 4 with only gas and 23 dry.
The set is a biased sample of all basins because of difficulties in obtaining data. Therefore the frequencies of oil, gas or dry in the learning set can not be taken to give prior probabilities.
The priors for Hydrocarbons (HC) in basins were estimated as follows from a total of 434, of which 29 not explored (hence unknown HC content). Remainder, 405 basins to be used.
|Classification||Number of basins||Prior probability|
|Non-associated gas only||25||P[OIL|HC]=0.794|
|Oil only, no NAG||34||P[NAG|OIL]=0.54|
Then a discriminant analysis was carried out with 8 geological variables that could be estimated in all the learning set basins. Four of these proved to be significant in classifying basins into dry or oil or gas-only. The parameters can be roughly related to factors of fulfillment, and hence "proxy variables".
It stands to reason that in this analysis it transpired that basin volume is not a significant factor for discrimination, though for the volume of HC it is. The discrimination on the basis of the four variables takes place in 4-dimensional space, which we can only show in two dimensions with the help of a "non-linear mapping" program. This gives the least-distorted projection of points in 4-D onto a 2-D map, of which the scale is irrelevant.
The separation is very nice. Also interesting: the non-associated gas basins from a special group in the center-left of the cloud.
We can conclude from this research that:
What has been described above for sedimentary basins is, with some modifications, also applicable to plays.
There has been much hope that "Basin Classification" would be very helpful in estimating basin resources. Unfortunately, the variety of petroleum systems within basins is often greater than the inter-basin variance. Thus general tectonic classification is less predictive than one might hope for (Bally et al., 1980, Klemme, 1971, Halbouty, 1970). However, it is interesting to read the discussion about this in a document "not-needed-basin-calssification" on the Scribd site on the internet, by ONGC, India.